Home > The Thinking > Articles > Palestinians must avoid a divisive trap

Palestinians must avoid a divisive trap


07-11-2012
English | العربية

Mohammad Fadhel Al Obaidly

Advisor, Public Opinion Research Center


Tag: Public Policy Middle East Government Policy
A+ A-

 
From the black years of the Lebanese civil war comes a tale that reveals the real nature of a statesman. Beirut was then a divided city, with the power stations in the eastern part of the city.Thus the people of west Beirut often paid a price darkness and blackouts.


From the heart of darkness, ordinary people and many politicians thought that the solution would be to build new power stations in the western part of the city. They were pushing the then Lebanese prime minister, Dr Saleem Al Hoss, to build power stations in west Beirut.


Ostensibly, it was a very legitimate and logical demand, one that could alleviate the suffering of the people in west Beirut. However, Al Hoss refused persistently to do so even when he was threatened by some of his cabinet members. The leader said that if he built power stations in west Beirut, it would further contribute to the division of Beirut.


That was in the mid 1980s. At that time, neither Al Hoss nor any Lebanese person would have dared to think that Beirut would unite again and the civil war would end. So what made Al Hoss refuse to take a step that could have helped him gain popularity? What kind of belief was motivating him to oppose what looked like a very legitimate demand from a lot of people?


Since 2007, Palestinian land has been divided between two rival Palestinian factions Gaza dominated by Hamas and West Bank by Fatah. I would never say that one of the two parts is better than the other or this part deserves aid and support, not the other.


Gaza, which has been under an Israeli siege since 2007, deserves all kinds of support and the brutal siege should end. But for this to happen, many might think exactly like those in Lebanon, who had thought about solving a problem in part by contributing to divisions of their own capital.


The visit of the Emir of Qatar to Gaza, two weeks ago reminded one of the story of west and east Beirut in those black years of the Lebanese civil war. Apart from that, aid trucks crossed the Egyptian-Palestinian border and there was an announcement of $400 million (Dh1.47 billion) in aid to the besieged Strip, The Emir called on the Palestinian National Authority (PNA) and Hamas to work together for unity.


For me and many others, a very logical question is: Why didnt he continue his move and visit Ramallah to meet the PNA President, Mahmoud Abbas? At least that would have fulfilled the two aims of the visit standing by the people of Gaza and garnering support for Palestinian unity.


Many reports and leaks about the Emir's visit say that Abbas was supposed to meet the Emir in his first hours in Gaza, but declined at the last moment under pressure from other Palestinian leaders. Whether this is true is not the issue.  Rather, for whatever reason, the reaction to the omission only proves that a long-awaited visit to Ramallah remains absolutely logical.


An event such as this is what makes fears of a Palestinian division so very tangible. The people of Gaza deserve all kinds of aid and support, but Palestinian unity deserves even more because it is the key to strengthening all Palestinians in their struggle against Israel by all means.


Unwanted consequences


Support to Palestinians should not be tailored on the basis of any Palestinian division. The people of Gaza deserve full support as do the Palestinians in the West Bank. Good intentions may lead to unwanted consequences, specially in politics and in fierce conflicts such as the Arab-Israeli contention.


What is left now is only a reproduction of that old, destructive Palestinian tale of resistance and betrayal resistor Hamas and armistice-seeker Fatah. What we see now after the visit (actually since 2007) is a distorted restoration of an old chapter in the unhappy history of Palestinian struggle.


The late Yasser Arafat had a long sojourn with rival Palestinian leaders. When he was alive, he faced constant defamation, but when he passed away, all his rivals, including Hamas, called him a martyr.


With Palestinian unity tenuous and Hamas leaders delight in the new situations in countries like Egypt and Tunisia whose new leaders talk only about aiding Gaza one hopes that Hamas leaders will not use the suffering of the people of Gaza as an excuse to consolidate their rule and ignore the bigger issue of Palestinian unity. If they fall into this trap, they will actually contribute to Palestinian division exactly the kind that Al Hoss had avoided in Lebanon decades ago.

Orginally published in Gulf News on November 5 2012

Receive more b'huth articles

Login to Comment

Don't Have Account? Create New
Forget Your Password? Click here
Enter Email Address

Also by Same Author

Defining the objectives of the Health Care System
Mohammad Fadhel Al Obaidly
Developing Education: Fundamental Ideas
Mohammad Fadhel Al Obaidly
Foreign Labor: Time for a Review
Mohammad Fadhel Al Obaidly

Most Read Articles

The Economic Effects of Ramadan: An Analysis
Elizabeth McKinney-Bennett
Cyber Attacks: what we know and what we can do about it
Kay Wise
Happiness and Tolerance: A UAE Vision
Dr.Kenneth L. Wise

Receive more b'huth articles

Recent Comments: